| 1954 – 56 | Pearl Spurgin (H.A.) |
| 1956 – 58 | Frances Findlay (Everett M.) |
| 1958 – 60 | Jewel Reese (Ray) |
| 1960 – 62 | Margaret Kemp (Edward G.) |
| 1962 – 64 | Lila Hummel (Leonard G.) |
| 1964 – 66 | Virginia Gamboa (Anthony) |
| 1966 – 68 | Evie Bright (L.K.) |
| 1968 – 70 | Margaret McLeod (W.C.) |
| 1970 – 72 | Betty Sayler (Eugene J.) |
| 1972 – 74 | Bea Rockoff (Richard M.) |
| 1974 – 76 | Helen Cohen (Seymour A.) |
| 1976 – 79 | Jean Jensen (L.A.) |
| 1979 – 81 | Gloria Blackwell (Ray) |
| 1981 – 83 | Wynona Gardner (Howard) |
| 1983 – 85 | Norma Downs (William) |
| 1985 – 87 | Rosann Turigliatto (Paul) |
| 1987 – 89 | Rosaline Turnbull (John) |
| 1989 – 91 | Norma Nauman (Art) |
| 1991 – 93 | Dorothy Koutouratsas (Nikolas) |
| 1993 – 95 | Nancy Hammond (Don) |
| 1995 – 97 | Sharon Bartholomew (Robert) |
| 1997 – 99 | Pam Brady (David) |
| 1999 – 01 | Pamela Mohr (Ronald) |
| 2001 – 03 | Kathy Haworth (Tony) |
| 2003 – 05 | Lezlie Darling (Robert) |
| 2005 – 07 | Janice Sawyer (Tom) |
| 2007 – 09 | Kathy Corzine |
| 2009 – 11 | Tom Horn |
| 2011 – 13 | Vera Johnson (Charles) |
| 2013 – 15 | Anita Avrick (Andy) |
| 2015 – 17 | Michael Morgan (Karen) |
| 2017 – 19 | Martha Deutsch (Barry) |